What Most People Get Wrong
Here's where things get interesting—and where I see travelers stumble repeatedly.
The assumption that all mexico itineraries are basically the same? Wrong. A 7-night Eastern route hits completely different ports than a 7-night Western. The vibe changes. The excursion options shift. Even the passenger demographics vary.
I've watched families book what they thought was a relaxing beach vacation, only to discover their itinerary focused on cultural ports with limited swimming opportunities. The research matters. Actually, wait—the right research matters. Half of what you'll find online is outdated or written by people who've never actually taken the cruises they're describing.
The Ship Selection Question
Holland America operates several ships in this region, and they're not interchangeable.
Newer ships offer more amenities but attract more families and first-timers. Older ships have loyal followings of repeat cruisers who prefer the smaller crowds and familiar layouts. Neither choice is wrong—but one might be wrong for you.
View Holland America ship details
What I've noticed over years of sailing
The passengers who enjoy their cruises most are the ones who understood what they were getting before they booked. They didn't expect a party atmosphere on a luxury line. They didn't expect gourmet dining on a budget line. They matched their expectations to the product.
Shore Excursion Reality
Here's where cruise lines make their money—and where you can save yours.
Ship-sponsored excursions offer convenience and the guarantee that your ship will wait if the tour runs late. That's worth something. But it's not worth the 40-60% premium over booking similar tours independently.
The sweet spot? Book ship excursions for ports with complicated logistics (tender ports, limited transportation, language barriers). Go independent for ports where taxis are plentiful and attractions are walkable.
And those "free" walking tours advertised at ports? They're tip-based, not free. Budget $20-40 per person for a decent guide.
Timing Your Trip Right
Month selection matters more than most people realize.
The "best" month depends entirely on what you prioritize. Lowest prices? Shoulder season. Best weather? Peak season (with peak crowds). Fewest kids? When school is in session. Best value-to-experience ratio? Often the weeks immediately before or after major holidays.
I personally prefer late spring. The weather cooperates, the crowds thin slightly, and the pricing hasn't yet hit peak season premiums.
The Cabin Debate
I've stayed in every cabin category across multiple Holland America ships. Here's what that experience taught me:
Inside cabins work for active cruisers who treat the cabin as a sleep-only space. If you're poolside by 8 AM and not returning until midnight, why pay for a view you won't see?
Balcony cabins transform the experience for scenic routes. Waking up to glacier views or watching sunset over Mediterranean coastline from your private space—that's worth the upgrade.
Suites? They're about perks as much as space. Priority boarding, specialty dining access, concierge service—decide if those extras justify the 2-3x price increase.
Food and Dining Expectations
Cruise line dining has improved dramatically over the past decade. The included options—main dining room, buffet, casual venues—deliver better quality than ever.
But "better than ever" doesn't mean uniform. Holland America's specialty restaurants (extra charge) often rival excellent restaurants on land. The included venues serve good food, not great food.
My strategy: eat at included venues most nights, splurge on one or two specialty restaurant experiences, and never skip the room service breakfast option.
The Honest Assessment
After sailing this route multiple times, here's my balanced take:
What Works
- The convenience of unpacking once and waking up in new destinations
- Access to locations that would be complicated to visit independently
- The all-inclusive nature (accommodations, meals, entertainment, transportation)
- Quality has genuinely improved across most cruise lines
What Doesn't
- Port time is limited—you're sampling, not immersing
- Crowds at popular attractions coincide with multiple ship arrivals
- Onboard pricing for extras (drinks, excursions, WiFi) adds up quickly
- Some itineraries rush through ports that deserve more time
Making the Right Choice
If you value efficiency and convenience over depth of experience, cruising delivers exceptional value. You'll cover more ground in a week than most independent travelers manage in two.
If you prefer slow travel—settling into one place, discovering local rhythms, eating where locals eat—a cruise may frustrate you. The format doesn't support that approach.
Practical Booking Advice
Book during wave season (January-March) for best promotions. Deposit early to lock in pricing—most lines allow cancellation with full refund until final payment deadline.
Consider travel insurance. Not because cruises are dangerous, but because life is unpredictable. A canceled sailing or medical emergency is expensive without coverage.
And read the fine print. Gratuities, drink packages, shore excursion policies—understand what's included before you board.
Learn about flexible payment options
The Romantic Traveler Consideration
For romantic travelers specifically, a few additional thoughts:
The cruise format works well when you understand its limitations. You're trading depth for breadth, spontaneity for convenience. That's not a criticism—it's a trade-off worth understanding.
The best romantic cruise experiences come from travelers who plan appropriately: researching ports before arrival, booking excursions that match their interests, and setting realistic expectations for the onboard experience.
This guide reflects personal experience across multiple sailings. Pricing, policies, and offerings change regularly—verify current information with cruise lines before booking.